What Is the Best Zero Turn Mower According to Consumer Reports? | A Detailed & Easy Guide

If you’re planning to buy a zero-turn mower and want to make the smartest choice, it makes sense to ask: What is the best zero turn mower according to Consumer Reports?

Consumer Reports is one of the most trusted sources when it comes to testing and ranking products. They review mowers based on cutting performance, durability, comfort, ease of use, handling, and user satisfaction.

In this article, we explore straight-to-the-point article, you’ll discover which zero-turn mowers are top-rated by Consumer Reports and why they stand out from the rest.

⸻

✅ What Does Consumer Reports Look For in a Zero Turn Mower?

Before naming the best, let’s quickly understand how Consumer Reports tests mowers:

1. Cutting Quality: Does the mower cut evenly, without leaving uncut patches or tearing the grass?

2. Ease of Use: Are the controls intuitive? Is it easy to adjust the cutting height and maneuver?

3. Durability: Does it use quality materials? How well does it hold up over time?

4. Comfort: Is the ride smooth? Are the seats and handlebars comfortable for long mowing sessions?

5. Owner Satisfaction: What do real buyers say after using it for a year or more?

Now, let’s look at the zero-turn mowers that scored highest based on these factors.

⸻

What Is the Best Zero Turn Mower According to Consumer Reports? | Best Zero Turn Mower According Reports (2025 Update)

🏆

1. Toro TimeCutter MyRIDE Series – #1 Overall

Why It’s the Best:

• Excellent cutting performance

• Unique MyRIDE suspension system for extra comfort

• Reliable, strong engine (Kawasaki or Kohler options)

• Easy-to-use controls and maintenance-friendly

Consumer Reports Score:

Rated highest overall for cut quality, comfort, and ease of control.

Best For:

Homeowners with medium to large lawns who want a smooth, fast mowing experience.

⸻

2. Husqvarna Z254F – Best for Power and Reliability

Why Consumers Love It:

• 54” fabricated deck for wider coverage

• Briggs & Stratton or Kawasaki engine (powerful and long-lasting)

• Great traction and easy maneuvering

• Rugged frame built for years of use

Consumer Reports Highlights:

• High scores in durability, performance, and cutting width

• Great for yards with slight hills or uneven spots

Best For:

Users who want a reliable, tough mower that handles bigger jobs with ease.

⸻

3. Cub Cadet Ultima ZT2 – Best for Value and Features

Why It’s Highly Rated:

• Comfortable high-back seat with armrests

• Dual LED headlights for early or late mowing

• Open frame design for easy cleaning and maintenance

• 23–24 HP engines and smooth twin hydrostatic transmission

Consumer Reports Notes:

• Very high in owner satisfaction and value-for-money

• Performs exceptionally well for its price

Best For:

First-time buyers or homeowners who want premium features without the premium price.

⸻

4. John Deere Z530R – Best for Long-Term Use

Why It’s Popular:

• Built like a tank with long-lasting parts

• Available with powerful 24–25 HP engines

• Offers wide deck options (up to 60”)

• Extremely comfortable to ride with smooth steering

Consumer Reports Review:

• Rated best for build quality and resale value

• Loved for long-term dependability

Best For:

Users who see their mower as a long-term investment and want top-tier support.

⸻

🔍 Consumer Reports Comparison Table

Brand & Model Best Feature CR Strengths Ideal For

Toro TimeCutter MyRIDE Ultimate comfort Cut quality, comfort, controls Smooth mowing on large lawns

Husqvarna Z254F Rugged power Durability, traction, wide coverage Larger or slightly hilly yards

Cub Cadet ZT2 High value + comfort Owner satisfaction, feature-rich design Budget-conscious homeowners

John Deere Z530R Long-term investment Reliability, resale, quality Professionals & serious homeowners

⸻

🧠 Consumer Reports Buying Tips

1. Match the mower to your yard size:

Don’t overspend on features you won’t use. A 42” deck is enough for most ½-acre yards. Go larger for 2+ acres.

2. Think about comfort:

If you mow often, choose one with good suspension and a cushioned seat.

3. Check service and support:

Consumer Reports also considers how easy it is to get parts and service locally.

4. Stick to trusted engines:

Brands using Kawasaki or Kohler engines tend to last longer and run smoother.

⸻

✅ Final Verdict: Which Zero Turn Mower Is the Best According to Consumer Reports?

👉 Toro TimeCutter MyRIDE takes the top spot overall—for performance, comfort, and satisfaction.

👉 Husqvarna Z254F is best if you want durability and power.

👉 Cub Cadet Ultima ZT2 offers top features at a more affordable price.

👉 John Deere Z530R is unmatched for long-term value and professional-quality results.

No matter which one you pick, choosing from these Consumer Reports top-rated models means you’re getting a mower that’s trusted, tested, and built to impress.

⸻

💬 FAQs

Q1: What engine type is best in a zero-turn mower?

Kawasaki and Kohler engines are rated the highest for long-term reliability.

Q2: What size deck should I get?

• Under ½ acre: 42” deck

• ½–2 acres: 48”–54” deck

• Over 2 acres: 60”+ deck

Q3: Is Toro better than Husqvarna?

Toro ranks higher for comfort, but Husqvarna wins in rugged performance. It depends on what matters more to you.

Q4: How long do zero-turn mowers last?

A good model can last 10–15 years or more with regular maintenance.

Q5: Do these brands have good customer service?

Yes—all four brands (Toro, Husqvarna, Cub Cadet, John Deere) have wide service networks and warranty support.

⸻